If you’re considering converting your masonry fireplace to better suit your heating needs, choosing the right insert is essential. For larger, traditional fireplaces, the Comfort Glow Wood Fireplace Insert CGWI1800 offers robust heating and a stylish look, but it requires space and manual loading. For those seeking a cleaner, easier upgrade, electric options like the PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert provide realistic flames and ambiance without the mess of wood, though they can’t replace full heating capacity. Meanwhile, the Ashley Hearth AW1820E stands out for substantial heat output suitable for large spaces, but demands freight delivery and is limited to masonry fireplaces. To add a modern twist with smart features, the Touchstone Fireplug combines realistic visuals with home automation, ideal for smaller rooms. These picks balance different priorities—efficiency, ambiance, ease of installation—so understanding your space and needs guides the best choice.
Key Takeaways
- The Comfort Glow CGWI1800 offers high heat output but requires manual log loading and installation space.
- Electric inserts like PuraFlame and Touchstone provide realistic flames with minimal mess but are not primary heat sources.
- The Ashley Hearth insert delivers high BTUs for large spaces but involves freight shipping and dedicated masonry installation.
- Smart features in the Fireplug model enhance ambiance control, ideal for tech-savvy users in small to medium rooms.
- Choosing between wood and electric conversions depends heavily on your space, desired realism, and installation preferences.
| Comfort Glow Wood Fireplace Insert CGWI1800 |  | Best Overall for Large Spaces | Log Capacity: 18 inches | Heating Area: up to 1,200 sq ft | Blower: 100 CFM | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound |  | Best for Ambiance and Ease of Use | Overall dimensions: 35 1/16″ W x 26 31/32″ H x 8 25/32″ D | Firebox dimensions: 32 1/8″ W x 25 9/16″ H x 7 51/64″ D | Flame intensity: 3 levels | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| PuraFlame Western 33″ Electric Fireplace Insert with Trim Kit |  | Best for Modern Interior & Custom Flame Settings | Dimensions: 44.1″ W x 31.5″ H x 8.8″ D | Flame Settings: 3 with adjustable brightness and intensity | Heat Output: 750/1500W | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Ashley Hearth AW1820E 1,200 Sq. Ft. Wood Stove Insert |  | Best for High Heating Capacity | Heating Capacity: 1200 sq ft | BTUs: 69,000 | Firebox Size: 1.2 cubic feet | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Touchstone Fireplug 29″ Electric Fireplace Insert |  | Best for Smart Home & Customization | Dimensions: 29″ W x 24″ H (face) | Heated Area: up to 400 sq ft | Flame Colors: 6 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| masonry fireplace conversion insert wood | Dimensions |
|---|---|
| Comfort Glow Wood Fireplace In | Fits 18" logs |
| PuraFlame Western Electric Fir | — |
| PuraFlame Western 33" Electric | 44.1" W x 31.5" H x 8.8" D |
| Ashley Hearth AW1820E 1,200 Sq | — |
| Touchstone Fireplug 29" Electr | 29" W x 24" H (face) |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Comfort Glow Wood Fireplace Insert CGWI1800
The Comfort Glow CGWI1800 stands out as a versatile, heavy-duty wood insert capable of heating up to 1,200 sq ft. Its steel construction ensures durability, while the 100 CFM blower helps distribute heat evenly, making it an excellent choice for large living areas. Compared with electric options, it provides the authentic experience of a wood fire, but it requires space, manual loading, and a proper chimney setup. Its EPA compliance guarantees cleaner burning, although the weight and installation complexity might deter those seeking a straightforward upgrade. Overall, this model offers a reliable, traditional heating solution for homeowners committed to wood burning, despite the added installation effort.
Pros:- Efficient heating for large areas up to 1,200 sq ft
- Heavy-duty steel build ensures longevity
- Includes blower for better heat circulation
- Stylish decorative faceplate enhances aesthetics
Cons:- Requires significant installation space
- Manual loading can be inconvenient
- Heavy and potentially difficult to move
Best for: Large spaces and traditional wood fire enthusiasts
Not ideal for: Small rooms or those preferring low-maintenance electric options
- Log Capacity:18 inches
- Heating Area:up to 1,200 sq ft
- Blower:100 CFM
- Material:Heavy-duty steel
- Dimensions:Fits 18″ logs
- Compliance:EPA 2020 standards
Our verdict“A robust, dependable choice for homeowners wanting authentic wood heating in large spaces, but with installation and manual effort tradeoffs.”
PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound
This electric insert offers stunning visual effects with realistic flames and crackling sounds, creating a cozy fireplace ambiance without the mess of wood. Its sleek design, interior brick accents, and remote control make it a popular choice for upgrading existing masonry fireplaces where primary heating isn’t critical. However, compared to traditional wood inserts, it cannot heat large spaces or replace a real fireplace, making it suitable primarily for ambiance and supplemental heat up to 400 sq ft. Its plug-in setup is straightforward, but it falls short for those needing substantial warmth or authentic combustion experience.
Pros:- Realistic flame effects with crackling sound
- Energy-efficient LED technology
- Easy to install with remote control
- Stylish interior brick accents
Cons:- Not suitable as primary heat source
- Limited to 400 sq ft coverage
- Requires flat surface and plug-in power
Best for: Small to medium rooms seeking ambiance and supplemental heat
Not ideal for: Large spaces or primary heating needs
- Overall dimensions:35 1/16″ W x 26 31/32″ H x 8 25/32″ D
- Firebox dimensions:32 1/8″ W x 25 9/16″ H x 7 51/64″ D
- Flame intensity:3 levels
- Heat output:750/1500W
- Coverage area:up to 400 sq ft
- Power:120V
Our verdict“Ideal for adding ambiance in smaller rooms, but not a replacement for traditional heating or wood-burning fireplaces.”
PuraFlame Western 33″ Electric Fireplace Insert with Trim Kit
This electric insert combines realistic resin logs with adjustable flame settings, offering a modern aesthetic suitable for many interior styles. It provides supplemental warmth for rooms up to 400 sq ft and is easy to operate with a remote control. Similar to the previous electric model, it cannot replace a dedicated wood stove or serve as a primary heat source but excels in ambiance and style. Delivered in two packages, it may involve some assembly time and precise measurements for installation. It’s perfect for those who want a sophisticated look with customizable flames without the hassle of wood.
Pros:- Realistic resin logs and flame effects
- Multiple flame settings with variable brightness
- Energy-efficient LED technology
- Remote control included
Cons:- Not suitable as primary heat source
- Requires flat surface and careful measurement
- Delivered in multiple packages, which may arrive separately
Best for: Small rooms or interior upgrades focused on style
Not ideal for: Large spaces or primary heating needs
- Dimensions:44.1″ W x 31.5″ H x 8.8″ D
- Flame Settings:3 with adjustable brightness and intensity
- Heat Output:750/1500W
- Coverage Area:up to 400 sq ft
- Material:Resin logs, glass front
- Power Supply:120V
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“A stylish, customizable electric insert perfect for enhancing smaller spaces with modern design and ambiance.”
Ashley Hearth AW1820E 1,200 Sq. Ft. Wood Stove Insert
The Ashley Hearth AW1820E offers robust heating with up to 69,000 BTUs, making it suitable for spaces up to 1,200 sq ft. Its large firebox accommodates logs up to 18 inches, and the adjustable blower boosts heat distribution. While it excels in performance, it requires freight shipping, and installation is limited to masonry fireplaces, which could be a challenge for some homeowners. This model is better suited for those who prioritize powerful, wood-based heating over ease or aesthetics. Its durable steel and ceramic glass ensure long-term use, but the shipping logistics and installation costs can be notable barriers.
Pros:- High BTU output for large spaces
- Efficient secondary combustion reduces emissions
- Heavy-duty steel build for durability
- Adjustable blower enhances heat circulation
Cons:- Freight shipping required, curbside only
- No installation or assembly included
- Limited to masonry fireplaces
Best for: Large spaces needing primary wood heat
Not ideal for: Small rooms or those preferring electric convenience
- Heating Capacity:1200 sq ft
- BTUs:69,000
- Firebox Size:1.2 cubic feet
- Log Length:up to 18 inches
- Blower:150 CFM
- Firebox Material:Heavy 10-gauge reinforced plate steel
- Chimney Compatibility:6-inch liner
- EPA Compliance:Yes
Our verdict“A powerful, traditional wood insert for large spaces, but with logistical considerations and installation constraints.”
Touchstone Fireplug 29″ Electric Fireplace Insert
The Touchstone Fireplug combines realistic flames with smart technology, including WiFi and Alexa compatibility, making it ideal for tech-savvy users. It provides supplemental heat up to 400 sq ft and offers six customizable flame colors and thirteen ember options. Its ambient sound features add to the cozy atmosphere, and the remote control simplifies operation. While it excels in ambiance and convenience, it isn’t designed as a primary heating solution or suitable for large rooms. Its precise measurements and smart controls might pose a challenge for less tech-oriented homeowners, but for small spaces seeking a modern touch, it delivers impressive visual effects and smart features.
Pros:- Realistic flames with customizable colors
- Smart home compatibility with Alexa and WiFi
- Ambient crackling sound enhances realism
- Compact size and easy to operate
Cons:- Limited heating capacity for larger rooms
- Requires precise measurements for installation
- Setup may be complex for non-technical users
Best for: Small to medium rooms with smart home needs
Not ideal for: Large, primary heating spaces
- Dimensions:29″ W x 24″ H (face)
- Heated Area:up to 400 sq ft
- Flame Colors:6
- Ember Colors:13
- Additional Features:WiFi & Alexa compatible, crackling sound
- Power:1500W
Our verdict“A versatile, high-tech electric insert perfect for small spaces seeking ambiance and smart home integration.”
How We Picked
To determine the best masonry fireplace conversion inserts for wood, I evaluated each product based on heating capacity, ease of installation, realism, and compatibility with existing fireplaces. I prioritized products that are designed specifically for masonry conversions, considering whether they offer sufficient heat for large spaces or focus more on ambiance. Cost, durability, and user-friendly features like remote control or smart home compatibility also played key roles. I aimed to include a mix of traditional wood inserts and electric alternatives, ensuring options for different preferences and budgets. Each product was compared against similar models for tradeoffs like installation complexity and realism versus convenience.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Masonry Fireplace Conversion Insert Wood
When choosing a masonry fireplace conversion insert for wood, it’s key to consider your heating needs, space size, installation complexity, and whether you prefer traditional or electric options. Wood inserts like the Comfort Glow provide authentic heating but require more effort and space. Electric inserts, including models like PuraFlame and Touchstone, excel in ambiance and ease of use but don’t replace the full heat output of wood. The Ashley Hearth offers high BTUs for large spaces but involves shipping logistics. Understanding these factors helps narrow down the best fit for your home.
Heating Capacity and Space Size
If your goal is to heat a large living area, the Comfort Glow CGWI1800 and Ashley Hearth AW1820E provide substantial output that can cover up to 1,200 sq ft. Electric options like the PuraFlame models are better suited for small to medium rooms, offering ambiance but limited warmth. Match your fireplace choice to your room size to avoid over- or under-heating.
Ease of Installation and Maintenance
Wood inserts require chimney connections, space, and manual log handling, making installation more involved. Electric inserts are plug-and-play, with remote controls and less mess, ideal for quick upgrades. Consider whether you want to deal with freight shipping or prefer a straightforward, DIY-friendly electric model.
Realism and Aesthetics
Traditional wood inserts like the Comfort Glow deliver genuine flames and heat, but electric models like the Fireplug and PuraFlame excel in visual realism and ambiance, with customizable flames and sounds. Your preference for authenticity versus style shapes the best pick.
Smart Features and Modern Design
If controlling your fireplace remotely or integrating with smart home systems matters, the Touchstone Fireplug offers WiFi and Alexa compatibility, along with customizable flames. For a sleek, modern look that easily fits into contemporary interiors, electric inserts are generally more adaptable and less invasive.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use an electric fireplace insert as a primary heat source?
Most electric inserts, including the PuraFlame and Touchstone models, are designed for supplemental heating and are suitable for small to medium rooms. They typically cannot provide the same level of warmth as a dedicated wood stove or traditional fireplace insert, especially in larger spaces. If primary heating is your goal, a high-capacity wood insert like the Ashley Hearth is more appropriate.
What are the main differences between wood and electric fireplace inserts?
Wood inserts like the Comfort Glow and Ashley Hearth provide genuine heat and the authentic experience of burning logs, but they require chimney connections, manual loading, and more maintenance. Electric inserts, such as PuraFlame and Touchstone, offer hassle-free installation, cleaner operation, and realistic flames without actual combustion, making them ideal for ambiance and convenience but limited in heating capacity.
Are electric inserts safe to install in existing masonry fireplaces?
Yes, electric inserts are generally safe for installation in existing masonry fireplaces, provided the dimensions fit properly and the installation follows the manufacturer’s guidelines. They do not produce fumes or require chimney modifications, reducing safety concerns related to combustion gases. However, professional installation is recommended to ensure proper placement and electrical connections.
How do I decide between a wood and an electric insert?
Your choice depends on your heating needs, room size, and desire for authenticity versus convenience. If you want powerful, traditional heating with the ambiance of real fire, a wood insert like the Comfort Glow or Ashley Hearth makes sense. For easier setup, cleaner operation, and visual effects primarily for ambiance, electric options such as the Fireplug or PuraFlame are excellent, especially in smaller rooms.
What should I consider before installing a fireplace insert?
Measure your existing fireplace opening carefully and compare it with the insert dimensions to ensure proper fit. Consider the type of heat you need, whether you prefer manual or remote operation, and if your home can support the installation requirements, such as chimney compatibility or electrical wiring. Also, think about your maintenance willingness and aesthetic preferences, as these impact long-term satisfaction.
Conclusion
Choosing the right masonry fireplace conversion insert depends on your priorities. For large, traditional spaces where authentic wood heat is desired, the Comfort Glow CGWI1800 or Ashley Hearth AW1820E are ideal, despite their installation complexities. Those seeking ease, ambiance, and modern features should lean toward electric options like the Fireplug or PuraFlame, which are perfect for small to medium rooms and require minimal setup. Consider your space, budget, and whether you value realism or convenience to make the best choice for your home.
